What is a mutt?
What is a mutt?
The term "mutts" is often used to refer to mixed-breed dogs, or dogs that do not belong to a specific breed. While the term is commonly used in a casual or affectionate manner, it has also been the subject of controversy and debate within the dog breeding and ownership community.
We asked our breeder community about how they feel regarding the term, and the results were as follows:
Why we shouldn’t use the term “mutt”
One argument against using the term "mutts" is that it can be seen as derogatory or demeaning to mixed-breed dogs.
Some people feel that the term carries negative connotations and suggests that mixed-breed dogs are somehow inferior to purebred dogs. This view is often based on the belief that purebred dogs are more predictable in terms of appearance, temperament, and health, and that mixed-breed dogs may have a wider range of physical and behavioral characteristics.
Our community of breeders weighs in on this perspective:
“Individuals engaged in responsible cross-breeding efforts often face significant criticism, and the term is frequently used in a derogatory manner against them.”
“The problem with the term is that it's often used pejoratively against designer breeds. We should have distinct terminology for intentionally bred designer dogs versus random mixed-breed dogs. They're clearly different and shouldn't be lumped into the same category.”
Another argument against using the term "mutts" is that it can perpetuate negative stereotypes about mixed-breed dogs.
Some people believe that the term is often used to portray mixed-breed dogs as being less desirable, less valuable, or less worthy of care and attention. This view is often based on the belief that mixed-breed dogs are less likely to be adopted from shelters, and that they may be more likely to be euthanized due to overpopulation and lack of resources.
Our community of breeders weighs in on this perspective:
“A mutt is a mixed-breed dog without a specific breeding goal, while a hybrid is intentionally bred for a particular purpose, like sled dogs. The terms used should not convey emotional judgment; all dogs have value as living beings.”
“The term "mutt" feels negative to me, while "cross-bred" suggests purposeful breeding. For example, a service dog breeder crossed a Newfoundland with a Golden Retriever for specific traits. Six out of nine puppies from this pairing showed promise for service roles, like assisting veterans and first responders.”
Why we should use the term “mutt”
On the other hand, some people argue that the term "mutts" is simply a colloquial term that is used to describe mixed-breed dogs in a casual and affectionate manner, and that it is not intended to be derogatory or demeaning. They may also point out that mixed-breed dogs can be just as loving, loyal, and healthy as purebred dogs, and that the term "mutts" should not be used to diminish their value or worth.
Our community of breeders weighs in on this perspective:
“I frequently use the term "mutt" in an endearing way, even when referring to my purebred pets. However, it's unfortunate that a significant and vocal segment of dog enthusiasts can be incredibly harsh online, often belittling dogs and relentlessly criticizing their owners to feel morally superior. So, I'd argue that the context and tone in which the term is used are crucial.”
“The term "mutt" is factual, not emotional, and should be used as such. If you own a mixed-breed dog, own the term proudly. Emotional weight doesn't need to be attached to every descriptor, like "breeding bitch," which is used for clarity to specify an intact female dog.”
To “mutt” or not to “mutt?” 🧐
Ultimately, whether or not to use the term "mutts" is a matter of personal preference and individual belief.
Some people may prefer to use alternative terms to refer to mixed-breed dogs, such as "mixed breed," "designer dogs," or "hybrid dogs," while others may feel comfortable using the term "mutts" as a affectionate and casual way to describe mixed-breed dogs. Ultimately, the most important thing is to respect and value all dogs, regardless of their breed or background.
💡 Our TellTail community does not condone the use of the term “mutt” as a way to describe a dog in a demeaning manner.
